Home » Fiction


This story is rated «R», and carries the warnings «Angst, angst, and a little more angst to boot. Serious emotional issues, self-mutilation. Graphic violent imagery, not for the sensitive. But lots of Hurt/Comfort, and some fluff. Yes, fluff. No sex. Deal with it.».
Since you have switched on the adult content filter, this story is hidden. To read this story, you have to switch off the adult content filter. [what's this?]

Remember that whether you have the adult content filter switched on or off, this is always an adults only site.

Chronicle of Scars: Cuts (R) Print

Written by Dernhelm

29 March 2004 | 29961 words

[ all pages ]

Title: Chronicle of Scars: Cuts
Author: Dernhelm (dernhelm_3018@yahoo.com)
Pairing: Aragorn/Faramir
Rating: R (for violent imagery, not sexuality)
Summary: Sometimes the deepest wounds cannot be seen by the eye. Only by the soul.

Disclaimer: Characters, locations, and mythos are the property of the estate of Tolkien and New Line Cinema. I make no claims to them, I only borrow them for a bit of mischief.

Warnings: Angst, angst, and a little more angst to boot. Serious emotional issues, self-mutilation. Graphic violent imagery, not for the sensitive. But lots of Hurt/Comfort, and some fluff. Yes, fluff. No sex. Deal with it.

Authors Note: Takes place several years after ROTK. This story ties in with a previous fic,Love Me and Despair, although it is not necessary to read it first to understand this story. Mix of book and movie canons.

Thanks: Extra, extra-special thanks to Spouse, who is the world’s best Beta-reader and giver of unbiased feedback…esp. from a guy who doesn’t read slash.

Prologue: Parting

Faramir awoke alone again for the third time that week. He did not need to reach his hand out to know his wife did not lay beside him, the hollow that held her lithe body in the mattress long since turned cold.

The morning sun had not yet begun its ascent in the sky, and the moon still shone her pale face over Ithilien. Regardless, he had been robbed of sleep, as the knot that had been forming in his stomach for months twisted itself even tighter. Sighing, he rose from the bed, knowing it would do him no good to lay in the sheets that still smelled of her, making his wait for her even more torturous.

Not needing his robe, for the nights were balmy in this time when the spring ripened into summer, he settled himself into the large chair by the open window, letting the warm breezes dance upon the bare skin of his chest and arms. The view looked out upon the green hills of Emyn Arnen, upon which his fair house was built, but the peaceful view gave him no comfort this night. He picked up the carefully bound book on the table beside him and flipped through it, the fire-light long dimmed to smoldering coals and the moon too faint to truly read by, but still, it gave him something to do while he waited.

And waited.

The sky had begun to blush a tender violet when Faramir heard the door to the bed-chamber slowly open, and he held his breath as his beloved, his wife, the White Lady of Ithilien, whispered into the room. So intent was she on closing the door silently behind her that she did not notice the empty bed, nor her husband seated by the window.

“Good morning, Éowyn.” Faramir’s voice was calm and gentle, as he always was with her. Éowyn froze, clutching her chest in surprise, her eyes as wide as a frightened colt’s.

“How long have you been awake, my husband?” Éowyn’s voice trembled, but it was not faint. She had opted then, for the route of honesty. Faramir had always loved that about her.

“Long enough, my love.”

She turned her face away from him as the endearment passed his lips, and the knot in Faramir’s stomach tied itself a brother in his throat. He knew the truth then. All he had to do was hear it from her lips.

“You were with her again, weren’t you?” His voice held none of the hurt or accusations of a jilted lover, but the same placid tone he always took with her. This was going to be difficult enough. Hasty words would not lessen the bitterness.

She looked up at him after what seemed an eternity of silence, her eyes bright with unshed tears.

“Yes. I was.”

“You dreamt of the Lady again, didn’t you?”

“Yes. I did.”

Faramir sighed and rubbed the bridge of his nose, hiding his sorrow behind fatigue. She had confessed of her dreams one moonless night months before, after Faramir had woken in the darkness to find his wife’s face wet with tears, crying out a name softly as she slept: “Galadriel…”

In the morning he asked her why the great Lady’s name brought such pain, and after much careful persuasion, she had told him of her brief time in Lothlórien. She spoke of the radiant healer who had brought her back from the brink of death. She had wept openly when she told him about the burning nights they had spent in each others arms, and as Faramir held her tenderly, she told him of how the queen of the Elves had broken her young heart. The first love is always the cruelest. He had kissed her after she had finished her story, her lips salty with grief, attempting to soothe the ache that had never truly mended in her heart. He hoped to be able to heal her, to be able to fill the void in her soul with his endless love for her.

It was not enough. He had never been enough.

He knew what Éowyn needed. It would be the hardest thing he had ever done to actually give it to her now.

“You know that she has long since left this land, gone across the sea…”

Éowyn sat on the edge of the bed, and though it was only a few feet from Faramir’s chair, he felt as if a chasm had opened between them, so distant was the look in her eyes.

“I know. But, I, I can’t stop dreaming of her eyes, her voice, her…” she snapped out of her reverie, and flashed Faramir a nervous look, fear not masking her desire quickly enough before he saw it burning bright.

It was at that moment that his heart truly broke. He knew she would never speak of him with such reverence, such awe, such love. He was but a man, noble though he was, just a man. How could he ever measure up to such a fair and ancient creature? How could he ever compare with her first love?

“Then you must try and find her, Éowyn.” His voice remained even, determined not to betray the hot feelings roiling under his calm veneer.

Her blue eyes filled with disbelief. Did she truly understand him? Was he toying with her?

“You must stop these troubled dreams, my wife, or you will never know peace again.”

There was nothing but love for her in his eyes, and she knew his words were true.

“Faramir…I, I couldn’t do that to you.” She protested anyway, for although her love for the Lady overshadowed her love for her husband, she stilled cared deeply for him, hating herself for causing him such pain. “What would the people say of you? ‘There goes the cuckold Steward of Gondor, whose own wife left him for a living ghost?’”

“No, my dear. They will say, ‘There goes a man who loved his wife so much he could let her go to find her true happiness.’”

With those words, the tears she had been fighting fell fast and hard, though she did not sob or wail. She wished she could love him as he deserved, he was such a fine man. But she knew, in her heart of hearts, that no man could ever tame the grief her lost love had left her. Not even good Faramir.

She rose from her seat then, and kissed his cheek, his fine ginger stubble tickling her lips. Faramir closed his eyes and savored the kiss, asking nothing more of her, trying to ignore the sticky-sweet aroma of the handmaiden’s passion upon his wife. He clasped her hand tightly, and when she pulled it away, her golden wedding band lay in his palm, the metal still warm.

“Éowyn, know always that there is a place for you here in Gondor. If your quest should fail, and I pray it does not, do not be afraid to return. If you need my aid, do not be ashamed to ask it of me. You will always be my wife, and I will always honor that bond, if not in love, then in duty.”

His eyes were as dry as his throat, and words seemed to come from his mouth as if he were puppeting them. Already he had faded into numbness, for he would not show her his heartache.

He then quietly rose, and wrapping himself in his robe, for suddenly the morning air chilled him to the bone, he left her to gather her belongings. He did not look back as he left the chambers they had shared. He doubted he would ever sleep within their walls again.

Faramir watched from a high sentry post as his wife rode away over the lush hills, the orange light glinting off the morning dew and painting the normally green grass with hues to rival fire itself. He tasted copper in the back of his mouth, and only then realized that he had his tongue clamped tight enough between his teeth to draw blood.

She stopped and looked back at him once, her flaxen hair also capturing the blaze of the sunrise, making her appear ethereal, dreamlike. He raised his hand in farewell, the golden band on his finger flashing a beacon of thinly veiled hope to her, a reminder of what she left behind. And like a dream, she passed out of his life, his last vision that of her hair unfurling in the wind like a banner, burning itself forever on Faramir’s mind.

The first love is always the cruelest.

Only when she was out of his sight, only when he had strode back to his chambers, head held high, ignoring the curious glances from the early morning guards who had witnessed their Lady’s departure, did he truly acknowledge his grief.

Sinking into his chair, he stared at the ring on his hand, which seemed to blur slightly the longer he looked.

He felt hollow, as if a storm had swept through his soul, leaving nothing but a rattling husk behind. A cascade of raw anguish threatened to fill the void, to wash him away on the torrent.

He would not let that happen. He would not lose control of himself. He was the master of his emotions, not their slave.

With trembling hands, he opened the drawer on the table beside him, and pulled out the instrument of his denial. Cradling it like an old friend, Faramir eased his pain the only way he knew how.

NB: Please do not distribute (by any means, including email) or repost this story (including translations) without the author's prior permission. [ more ]

Enjoyed this story? Then be sure to let the author know by posting a comment at https://www.faramirfiction.com/fiction/chronicle-of-scars-cuts. Positive feedback is what keeps authors writing more stories!

9 Comment(s)

This is one of the most emotionally powerful stories I’ve ever read. I don’t think anyone could read it without being touched, even overwhelmed, by the poignant depths of emotion you explore here. Beautiful, painful, powerful. Perfect.

— Tal    Friday 20 March 2009, 20:16    #

Thank you, Tal, so much for your kind words. This is still one of my favorite stories that I’ve written, and to know folks are still enjoying it more than 4 years after it was written means a lot to me.

— Derhelm    Saturday 21 March 2009, 19:59    #

Wow. That is one of the most amazing things I have ever read, be it fanfiction or novel. I just sat down and read it from start to finish, because I couldn’t look away! The characterisation was perfect, in all cases (and you’ve written an Arwen that I love, and she’s often hard to write, especially in an Aragorn/Faramir story), and as Tal said, the emotional depth is just phenomenal. Thank you so much for writing something that was such a pleasure to read.

Amanda    Tuesday 24 March 2009, 4:48    #

I’ve never told you how much I love this story. I do love it. I have re-read it many times. The mindscape scene is both astonishing and believable, and I admire the hell out of you for coming up with it. Very well done. Thank you.

— Vanwa Hravani    Tuesday 24 March 2009, 14:47    #

This is one story I keep coming back to again and again. I think you handled the dark themes with superb sensitivity, and I too particularly like your portrayal of Arwen. Thank you for writing this!

— ophelia    Sunday 12 April 2009, 18:14    #

I’m back to this story yet again. Dernhelm, you’re quite hard to reach. If you’re still getting notes from this site, could you please contact me at the attached email?

Tal    Thursday 4 February 2010, 17:35    #

A great work, Dernhelm!
I do not remember when I was touched so deeply at the last time as I am touched with your story now.
Faramir’s inner world is so fascinated in your discription that I have no words.
I do not understand how Eowyn could treat so cruel with Faramir, but it’s interesting, had she found her love?!
Please, write more stories, you are an excellent author!
Thank you very much!

— Anastasiya    Tuesday 9 February 2010, 9:16    #

Truly wonderful. I think this is the third time I’ve read this fic now. I also like your Arwen in this story and usually I don’t. Faramir and Aragorn are great in this story. I would love to see more of this story. I think I wouldn’t even mind seeing all three (Aragorn/Arwen/Faramir) togeather.

— waterwolf    Wednesday 24 March 2010, 3:43    #

This is one of the best Faramir/Aragorn fics I think I’ve ever read. Your storycrafting is superb and this tale will remain in my mind and memory long after I’ve forgotten others.

— Dancingkatz    Wednesday 11 July 2012, 4:23    #

Subscribe to comments | Get comments by email | View all recent comments


  Textile help

All fields except 'Web' are required. The 'submit' button will become active after you've clicked 'preview'.
Your email address will NOT be displayed publicly. It will only be sent to the author so she (he) can reply to your comment in private. If you want to keep track of comments on this article, you can subscribe to its comments feed.


Hide | Show adult content

Adult content is shown. [what's this?]

Adult content is hidden.
NB: This site is still for adults only, even with the adult content filter on! [what's this?]


  • DE
  • ES
  • JP
  • FR
  • PT
  • KO
  • IT
  • RU
  • CN